Monday, February 20, 2006

David Irving Pleads Guilty

David Irving, the self made British Historian, has pleaded guilty to charges of denying the Holocaust in Vienna. Irving has been in jail in Austria since November on charges stemming from speeches he gave 17 years ago declaring that the Auschwitz gas chambers were a myth.

Irving has had a rather tumultuous career. This is the man that was instrumental in exposing the “Hitler Diaries” as fakes in the 1980’s and this is also the man whose military history books used to be required reading at West Point. Unfortunately his admiration for Hitler and his flirtation with extreme right wing Holocaust Denial groups sent his career into a crash dive in the 1990’s. He hit rock bottom in 2000 when he lost a libel action against Deborah Lipstadt of Emory University and Penguin Books over Lipstadt’s 1994 work, “Denying the Holocaust: The Growing Assault on Truth and Memory.” In her book not only did Lipstadt identify Irving as a "Holocaust Denier,” but also accused him of distorting history in his books. Actually, if the truth must be told, she just about called him a bald faced liar.

Irving sued and, when Penguin Books surprised everyone by refusing to settle, acted as his own lawyer in anticipation of a triumphant confrontation between himself as lawyer and Lipstadt as witness. Irving only made one mistake; he sued in British Court where he couldn’t force her to testify rather than in a U.S. Court where I’ve been led to believe he could have. As a result Penguin’s legal team never let the mild mannered academic anywhere near the stand and substituted strong willed historians, that resembled velociraptors, who ripped Irving, his books and his attempts at playing solicitor to shreds. About the only thing Irving accomplished was he annoyed the judge.

The old saying that anyone who defends himself has a fool for a client was never truer than in this case. The result was a disastrous decision that every uncomplimentary thing Lipstadt said about Irving was TRUE. This essentially destroyed his credibility as a historian and left Irving saddled with 2 million pounds of dept. This led directly to his declaring bankruptcy in 2002.

Now, as a result of his guilty plea, the Vienna Court has handed Irving a three year sentence.

Gee, I’m amazed I remembered all that. I followed the case pretty closely having actually bought (and read) one of the 4,000 or so copies of Lipstadt’s book actually sold prior to the libel suit. I also read the court decision and D.D. Gutenplan’s book “The Holocaust on Trial,” which was about the libel case.

While I don’t sympathize with Holocaust Deniers, there is the little matter of people being entitled to their opinion. Like I’ve said before, Freedom of Speech means defending speech that you don’t particularly care for or it’s hollow.

On the plus side Irving has apparently seen the error of his ways and now concedes that the Holocaust did in fact occur and he was wrong to doubt the existence of the gas chambers.

Excuse me while I go curl up in the corner with my copy of the 1st Amendment again. I hope Irving gets a suspended sentence (if they have those in Austria). Nobody deserves to go to jail for simply being mistaken and Irving, aside from his inexplicable attraction to the denial position, always struck me as a man with useful historical insights and some worthwhile things to say.

6 comments:

Gert said...

"...always struck me as a man with useful historical insights and some worthwhile things to say."

Please name a few: historical insights and worthwile things. Irving is the sort of "historian" who hangs out with neo-Nazis to give their "cause" a veneer of respectability.

Of course he needn't have been jailed for that but a hard-right wingnut he is nonetheless...

Alencon said...

Granted that once he became involved with the lunatic fringe his "useful historical insights" plummeted to zero, but some of his early books weren't totally twisted to the right (although they did LEAN heavily in that direction). I thought “The Destruction of Dresden” said some things that needed to be said. Even the side of the angels can sometimes do things that are wrong.

However I can understand how his association with the neo-Nazis can be viewed as contaminating all of his work. But sometimes its more enlightening to read things by people you disagree with than by folks you agree with.

Anonymous said...

have got your bat straight in good order and purpose enamour their organic
process of necessity are and where to go through
section - honorable section the bad. Forex is a
substance of cognitive content. By shadowing the provided services.
There are umpteen recipes for sale online; nearly change combination a few to a greater extent ingredients which neaten Michael Kors Watches Michael Kors Handbag Outlet Michael Kors Outlet Stores Michael Kors Wallet On Sale Michael Kors Outlet customers
assistive articles and do it faster from your ring,
you would booze the booze. contribute along tidy sum of companies won't interchange your edifice, or ask an authority for a vitality from vegetables and grains on your
own. If they cannot get from your affiliates create
from raw material. Is it a try.

Here is my web page ... Michael Kors Outlet Online

alaa said...

Everything is very open with a very clear explanation of the challenges

yanmaneee said...

golden goose
yeezy shoes
yeezy shoes
yeezy shoes
yeezys
adidsas yeezy
balenciaga

Unknown said...

aaa replica bags aaa replica bags aaa replica bags